1650 Green Bay, Lake Bluff IL 60044
Property Description
On the market for the first time in nearly 50 years, the historic Phelps Kelley House is one of Lake Bluff's most significant estate properties. Designed in 1927 by noted Chicago architect Ambrose Cramer, a protege of David Adler, this Tudor Revival masterpiece was originally part of the historic "Stonebridge" estate. The 9.35-acre property is elegantly situated at the end of a long, private, tree-lined drive, and features a pond, rolling lawn, mature trees, gardens, a 7,383-square-foot main residence with meticulously preserved interiors, and a detached 5-car garage with a full coach house apartment above. Across five decades, one family has carefully stewarded the character of this home, preserving its original grandeur through its stone floors, carved millwork, wood paneling, intricate moldings, tall casement windows, and generous ceiling heights. Cramer carefully planned the floorplan for gracious living and entertaining. A grand entry leads to expansive formal living and dining rooms-each with fireplaces and French doors opening to an expansive terrace overlooking verdant gardens and the pool beyond. A paneled sunroom offers a quiet retreat with views of the grounds and lends itself perfectly to a sun-filled private office. Service areas are thoughtfully configured for ease: a large butler's pantry with extensive vintage cabinetry connects the dining room to the kitchen, which adjoins a sunlit breakfast room oriented toward the pool. A spacious family room provides yet another vantage point to appreciate the property's natural beauty. Additional first-floor conveniences include a large laundry room, back staircase, and discreet storage integrated throughout. Five bedrooms and six full baths complete the second floor, including a primary suite that functions as its own private wing with dual baths, multiple closets, and a dressing room rich with period character. Two additional bedrooms and 1.1 baths on the first floor offer ideal space for guests or multi-generational living. The lower level includes a powder bath and abundant storage space, but could also be converted into a future recreation room. The property's park-like grounds elevate the estate into a true retreat that feels worlds away. Outdoor amenities include a swimming pool, greenhouse, and a prior tennis court site that provides exceptional potential for a new court or custom outdoor recreation. Meandering paths encourage exploration, while open lawns and a broad terrace facilitate gatherings of any scale. Adding to the estate's pastoral charm, the current owners maintain beehives on the property for small-batch honey production. The greenhouse, beehives, and expanses of lawn and garden reinforce the feeling of escape that a private country estate provides while being only minutes from Lake Bluff's beloved community fabric: downtown's charming shops and dining, the Metra station, Sunrise Beach, highly rated schools, outstanding parks, and the town's renowned Fourth of July celebration. A once-in-a-generation offering, the Phelps Kelley House represents the finest expression of North Shore heritage. It is an estate in the truest sense, meticulously preserved and ready to begin its next chapter.
Features & Information
Key Details
- List Price $6,250,000
- Property Taxes $54,382.94
- Square Feet 7383
- Price/ Sq. Ft. $846.54
- Year Built 1927
- Parking Type Garage
- Status Active
Rooms
- Total Rooms 13
- Basement F
-
Master Bedroom
- Master Bath F
- Room Size 20X21
-
Bedroom 2
- Room Size 19X20
- Floor Level 2nd Level
- Flooring Hardwood
-
Bedroom 3
- Room Size 13X17
- Floor Level 2nd Level
- Flooring Hardwood
-
Bedroom 4
- Room Size 21X18
- Floor Level 2nd Level
- Flooring Hardwood
-
Living Room
- Room Size 20X32
- Floor Level Main Level
- Flooring Hardwood
-
Family Room
- Room Size 30X19
- Floor Level Main Level
-
Dining Room
- Room Size 24X20
- Floor Level Main Level
- Flooring Hardwood
-
Kitchen
- Room Size 20X18
- Kitchen Type Eating Area-Breakfast Bar,Island,Pantry-Butler,Breakfast Room
- Floor Level Main Level
- Flooring Hardwood
-
Basement
- Basement Description Unfinished
- Bathroom(s) in Basement Y
Additional Rooms
-
Additional Room 1
- Additional Room 1 Name 5th Bdrm
- Additional Room Size 20X18
- Additional Room Level Main Level
- Additional Room Flooring Hardwood
-
Additional Room 2
- Additional Room 2 Name 6th Bdrm
- Additional Room Size 11X14
- Additional Room Level Main Level
- Additional Room Flooring Hardwood
Interior Features
-
Appliances
- Appliances Included Oven-Double, Microwave, Dishwasher, Refrigerator, Washer, Dryer, Compactor-Trash, Gas Cooktop
-
Heating & Cooling
- Heating Type Radiators
- Air Conditioning Space Pac
-
Fireplace
- # of Fireplaces 3
- Type of Fireplace Gas Logs,Gas Starter
Exterior Features
-
Building Information
- Age of Building 91-100 Years
- Exterior Construction Stone
-
Parking
- Parking Garage
- # of Cars 5
Location
- County Lake
- Township Shields
- Corporate Limits Lake Bluff
- Directions to Property From W Rockland Rd Go South On Green Bay Rd To Property
-
Schools
- Elementary School District 65
- School Name Lake Bluff Elementary Sch
- Junior High District 65
- School Name Lake Bluff Middle School
- High School District: 115
- School Name Lake Forest High School
-
Property Taxes
- Tax 54382.94
- Tax Year 2024
- Parcel Identification Number 12204000040000
-
Lot Information
- Dimensions 407386
- Acreage 9.3565
Utilities
- Sewer Septic-Pri
Listed by: Coldwell Banker Realty | Phone: 847.234.8000
Source: MRED as distributed by MLS GRID
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 3/14/2026 8:02 PM. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.
Mortgage Calculator
- List Price${ formatCurrency(listPrice) }
- Taxes${ formatCurrency(propertyTaxes) }
- Assessments${ formatCurrency(assessments) }
- List Price
- Taxes
- Assessments
Estimated Monthly Payment
${ formatCurrency(monthlyTotal) } / month
- Principal & Interest${ formatCurrency(monthlyPrincipal) }
- Taxes${ formatCurrency(monthlyTaxes) }
- Assessments${ formatCurrency(monthlyAssessments) }
All calculations are estimates for informational purposes only. Actual amounts may vary.